Observations on the Florid Song; Or, Sentiments on the Ancient and Modern Singers — Themes and Context

(0 User reviews)   384
In Category - Opera Performance
Tosi, Pier Francesco, 1653?-1732, Galliard, John Ernest, -1747 [Translator] Project Gutenberg 2008 Not confirmed
Singing; Performance practice (Music) -- Early works to 1800 Readers of public-domain and historical texts
Project Gutenberg digital edition en

Edition facts

Words 33,920
Reading time 148 min
Text sections 5

Observations on the Florid Song; Or, Sentiments on the Ancient and Modern Singers — Themes and Context can be approached with a clearer sense of reading commitment from its source measurements: 33,920 words, 2 hr 28 min estimated reading time, and 5 detected text sections.

The text analysis averages about 29.1 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.

Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “Singing,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.

Pier Francesco Tosi's 1723 treatise on florid singing, translated by John Ernest Galliard in 1743, contrasts ancient and modern vocal practices through pointed dialogue and vivid metaphors, revealing the author's conservative stance on ornamentation, taste, and the decline of the pathetic style.
Share
Editorial Edition Score 4.7/5

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

How this score is calculated
  • Description quality20 pts
  • Title & short description10 pts
  • Source metadata20 pts
  • Text length15 pts
  • Chapters / structure15 pts
  • EPUB file integrity20 pts

Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.

Edition quality

Read the Text

Singing was full of Expression and Passion; chiefly in the Stile of Chamber-Musick. The best Performers in his Time thought themselves happy when they could have an Opportunity to hear him. After he had lost his Voice, he apply'd himself more particularly to Composition; of which he has given Proof in his _Cantata's_, which are of an exquisite Taste, especially in the _Recitatives_, where he excels in the _Pathetick_ and _Expression_ beyond any other. He was a zealous Well-wisher to all who distinguished themselves in Musick; but rigorous to those who abused and degraded the Profession. He was very much esteemed by Persons of Rank among whom the late Earl of _Peterborough_ was one, having often met him in his Travels beyond Sea; and he was well received by his Lordship when in _England_, to Whom he dedicated this Treatise. This alone would be a sufficient Indication of his Merit, his being taken Notice of by a Person of that Quality, and distinguishing Taste. The Emperor _Joseph_ gave him an honourable Employment _Arch-Duchess_ a Church-Retirement in some part of _Italy_, and the late _Flanders_, where he died. As for his _Observations_ and _Sentiments_ on Singing, they must speak for themselves; and the Translation of them, it is hoped, will be acceptable to Lovers of Musick, because this particular Branch has never been treated of in so distinct and ample a Manner by any other Author. Besides, it has been thought by Persons of Judgment, that it would be of Service to make the Sentiments of our Author more universally known, when a false Taste in Musick is so prevailing; and, that these Censures, as they are passed by an _Italian_ upon his own Countrymen, cannot but be looked upon as impartial. It is incontestable, that the Neglect of true Study, the sacrificing the Beauty of the Voice to a Number of ill-regulated Volubilities, the neglecting the Pronunciation and Expression of the Words, besides many other Things taken Notice of in this Treatise, are all _bad_. The Studious will find, that our Author's Remarks will be of Advantage, not only to Vocal Performers, but likewise to the Instrumental, where Taste and a Manner are required; and shew, that a little less _Fiddling_ with the _Voice_, and a little more _Singing_ with the _Instrument_, would be of great Service to Both. Whosoever reads this Treatise with Application, cannot fail of Improvement by it. It is hoped, that the Translation will be indulged, if, notwithstanding all possible Care, it should be defective in the Purity of the _English_ Language! it being almost impossible (considering the Stile of our Author, which is a little more figurative than the present Taste of the _English_ allows in their Writings,) not to retain something of the Idiom of the Original; but where the Sense of the Matter is made plain, the Stile may not be thought so material, in Writings of this Kind.

Excellency the Earl of PETERBOROUGH, General of the Marines of _Great-Britain_.

I Should be afraid of leaving the World under the Imputation of Ingratitude, should I any longer defer publishing the very many Favours, which _Your Lordship_ so generously has bestow'd on me in _Italy_, in _Germany_, in _Flanders_, in _England_; and principally at your delightful Seat at _Parson's-Green_, where _Your Lordship_ having been pleased to do me the Honour of imparting to me your Thoughts with Freedom, I have often had the Opportunity of admiring your extensive Knowledge, which almost made me overlook the Beauty and Elegance of the Place. The famous _Tulip-Tree_, in your Garden there is not so surprising a Rarity, as the uncommon Penetration of your Judgment, which has sometimes (I may say) foretold Events, which have afterwards come to pass. But what Return can I make for so great Obligations, when the mentioning of them is doing myself an Honour, and the very Acknowledgment has the Appearance of _Vanity_? It is better therefore to treasure them up in my Heart, and remain respectfully silent; only making an humble Request to _Your Lordship_ that you will condescend favourably to accept this mean Offering of my OBSERVATIONS; which I am induc'd to make, from the common Duty which lies upon every Professor to preserve Musick in its Perfection; and upon Me in particular, for having been the first, or among the first, of those who discovered the noble Genius of your potent and generous Nation for it. However, I should not have presum'd to dedicate them to a Hero adorn'd with such glorious Actions, if _Singing_ was not a Delight of the Soul, or if any one had a Soul more sensible of its Charms. On which account, I think, I have a just Pretence to declare myself, with profound Obsequiousness,

Pier Francesco Tosi's Observations on the Florid Song opens with a striking prefatory address that immediately establishes the translator's agenda: to make 'a famous Italian Master' familiar to England. The work itself, originally published in Bologna in 1723 and translated by John Ernest Galliard in 1743, is structured as a series of numbered paragraphs that blend technical instruction with polemical commentary. Tosi's voice emerges through a distinctive rhetorical strategy: he frequently stages imaginary dialogues with unnamed 'Modern' singers, allowing their brash assertions to serve as foils for his own conservative views. The translator's note clarifies that 'by the Ancient, our Author means those who liv'd about thirty or forty Years ago'—a temporal frame that already signals the treatise's preoccupation with recent decline rather than remote history.

Dialogue as Polemical Device

Tosi repeatedly constructs confrontational exchanges to dramatize the clash between old and new schools. In one such passage, he recounts asking a modern composer 'from whom he had learned the Counterpoint?' only to be met with the retort: 'What Tone! what Tone! (breaking in upon me abruptly) with what musty Questions are you going to disturb my Brains?' The imagined interlocutor dismisses traditional modal theory, declaring that 'the Moderns, if you do not know it, acknowledge no other Tone but one.' This device allows Tosi to ventriloquize the very attitudes he condemns, making his own positions clearer by contrast. The dialogue form also injects a dramatic, almost theatrical energy into what might otherwise be a dry pedagogical text.

The Pathetic Style Under Siege

Tosi laments that modern singers have 'banish for ever the Pathetick' because 'we will have no Melancholy.' This complaint is not merely aesthetic but moral: he associates the loss of pathos with a broader corruption of musical purpose. In a striking metaphor, he warns that church music risks being degraded to 'Jiggs, Minuets, and Furlana's' if money were taken at the doors—a jab at the commercialization of sacred spaces. The translator's annotations, marked by bracketed numbers, occasionally gloss these references, but Tosi's own prose carries the argument through vivid, almost satirical imagery. His insistence on the primacy of vocal music over instrumental, and on the voice's power to 'express Sounds with greater Nicety and Exactness,' underpins his defense of the older, more expressive style.

Metaphors of Decay and Defense

Tosi's language is rich with metaphors that frame musical change as decline. The moderns, he writes, 'strive who can produce most extravagant Absurdities never heard before,' and they boast of their inventions while 'Envy burst.' He depicts the ancient style as beleaguered: a musician not of the modern 'Tribe' will 'find no Patron or Admirer,' and a few syllables—'He is an Ancient'—suffice to ruin him. Yet Tosi also grants his opponents a voice, as when the modern defender claims that 'our delicious Stile has been invented to hide with the fine Name of Modern the too difficult Rules of the Counterpoint.' This concession, placed in the mouth of the adversary, subtly acknowledges that the new style may be a response to complexity, even as Tosi rejects it.

The Translator's Mediating Role

John Ernest Galliard's translation is itself a layer of interpretation. His prefatory discourse addresses 'ALL Lovers of MUSICK' and frames the work as a service to the public, claiming he was 'more easily prevail'd upon to engage in this Work' to make Tosi 'familiar to England.' Galliard adds 'Explanatory Annotations, and Examples in Musick,' though the excerpts here include only the bracketed footnote numbers without the actual notes. The translator's presence is felt in the polished eighteenth-century English prose, which smooths Tosi's Italian into a flowing, argumentative style. The note on the meaning of 'Ancient' and 'Modern' is a crucial editorial intervention, defining terms that might otherwise confuse readers unfamiliar with the narrow temporal window Tosi intends.

Readers approaching this treatise should attend to the interplay between Tosi's numbered paragraphs and the imagined dialogues that puncture them. The work is less a systematic manual than a series of pointed observations, each carrying the weight of personal experience and partisan conviction. Galliard's translation preserves the combative energy of the original, making it a document not only of vocal pedagogy but of the cultural wars that surrounded Italian opera in the early eighteenth century. The annotations, though absent from this excerpt, likely amplify the technical dimension; even without them, the text rewards attention to its rhetorical strategies and historical specificity.

Tosi’s jealousy for the “pathetic style” always makes me a little melancholy, as if he’s mourning something already slipping away in 1723. I feel that same ache when I open Physiology of the Opera — A Reader’s Guide, which watches a later, brasher age from the wings. Both are private elegies for a kind of singing that now only hums between the lines.

There are no reviews for this eBook.

0
0 out of 5 (0 User reviews )

Add a Review

Your Rating *
There are no comments for this eBook.

Reader reflection

Your personal reading reflection

Build a private reading journal entry for this title.

Your progress 0 / 10
1

What is your current status with this title?

2

How much did you enjoy the reading experience?

3

Would you pass this book on to a friend?

4

Did the language feel accessible?

Related eBooks